After Child’s Minor Bike Accident, Main Invoice Units Authorized Wheels in Movement


Adam Woodrum was out for a motorcycle trip along with his spouse and children on July 19 when his then 9-year-old son, Robert, crashed.

“He lower himself fairly dangerous, and I might inform immediately he wanted stitches,” stated Woodrum.

As a result of they have been on bikes, he referred to as the hearth division in Carson Metropolis, Nevada.

“They have been nice,” stated Woodrum. “They took him on a stretcher to the ER.”

Robert acquired stitches and anesthesia at Carson Tahoe Regional Medical Middle. He’s since recovered properly.

Then the denial letter got here.

Ship Us Your Medical Payments

Do you may have an exorbitant or baffling medical invoice? Be a part of the KHN and NPR ‘Invoice of the Month’ Membership and inform us about your expertise. We’ll characteristic a brand new one every month.

Submit Your Invoice

The Affected person: Robert Woodrum, coated underneath his mom’s medical health insurance plan from the Nevada Public Workers’ Advantages Program

Complete Invoice: $18,933.44, billed by the hospital

Service Supplier: Carson Tahoe Regional Medical Middle, a part of not-for-profit Carson Tahoe Well being

Medical Service: Stitches and anesthesia throughout an emergency division go to

What Provides: The Aug. 4 rationalization of advantages (EOB) doc stated the Woodrum’s declare had been rejected and their affected person duty could be your complete sum of $18,933.44.

This case entails an all-too-frequent dance between various kinds of insurers about which one ought to pay a affected person’s invoice if an accident is concerned. All sides do their finest to keep away from paying. And, no shock to Invoice of the Month followers: When insurers can’t agree, who will get a scary invoice? The affected person.

The authorized title for the method of figuring out which kind of insurance coverage is primarily accountable is subrogation.

Might one other coverage — say, auto or residence protection or employees’ compensation — be obligated to pay if somebody was at fault for the accident?

Subrogation is an space of regulation that permits an insurer to recoup bills ought to a 3rd get together be discovered liable for the damage or harm in query.

Well being insurers say subrogation helps maintain down premiums by reimbursing them for his or her medical prices.

About two weeks after the accident, Robert’s mother and father — each legal professionals — received the EOB informing them of the insurer’s determination.

The notice additionally directed inquiries to Luper Neidenthal & Logan, a regulation agency in Columbus, Ohio, that focuses on serving to insurers get better medical prices from “third events,” that means individuals discovered at fault for inflicting accidents.

The agency’s web site boasts that “we acquire over 98% of recoverable {dollars} for the State of Nevada.”

One other letter additionally dated Aug. 4 quickly arrived from HealthScope Advantages, a big administrative agency that processes claims for well being plans.

The declare, it stated, included billing codes for care “generally used to deal with accidents” associated to car crashes, slip-and-fall accidents or office hazards. Underlined for emphasis, one sentence warned that the denied declare wouldn’t be reconsidered till an enclosed accident questionnaire was stuffed out.

Adam Woodrum, who occurs to be a private damage lawyer, runs into subrogation on a regular basis representing his purchasers, lots of whom have been in automobile accidents. Nevertheless it nonetheless got here as a shock, he stated, to have his well being insurer deny fee as a result of there was no third get together liable for their son’s strange bike accident. And the denial got here earlier than the insurer received details about whether or not another person was at fault.

“It’s like deny now and pay later,” he stated. “You could have insurance coverage and pay for years, then they are saying, ‘That is denied throughout the board. Right here’s your $18,000 invoice.’”

Though Adam Woodrum is a private damage lawyer, he says it nonetheless got here as a shock to have his well being insurer deny the declare after his son, Robert, received stitches in July following a motorcycle crash. (Maggie Starbard for KHN)
Woodrum and his son, Robert, get able to bike close to their residence in Carson Metropolis, Nevada, on Nov. 7. (Maggie Starbard for KHN)

When contacted, the Public Workers’ Advantages Program in Nevada wouldn’t remark particularly on Woodrum’s state of affairs, however a spokesperson despatched info from its well being plan paperwork. She referred inquiries to HealthScope Advantages about whether or not this system’s coverage is to disclaim claims first, then search extra info. The Little Rock, Arkansas-based agency didn’t return emails asking for remark.

The Nevada well being plan’s paperwork say state laws permits this system to get better “any and all funds made by the Plan” for the damage “from the opposite particular person or from any judgment, verdict or settlement obtained by the participant in relation to the damage.”

Legal professional Matthew Anderson on the regulation agency that handles subrogation for the Nevada well being plan stated he couldn’t converse on behalf of the state of Nevada, nor might he remark straight on Woodrum’s state of affairs. Nevertheless, he stated his insurance coverage trade purchasers use subrogation to recoup funds from different insurers “as a cost-saving measure,” as a result of “they don’t wish to move on excessive premiums to members.”

Regardless of shoppers’ unfamiliarity with the time period, subrogation is frequent within the medical health insurance trade, stated Leslie Wiernik, CEO of the Nationwide Affiliation of Subrogation Professionals, the trade’s commerce affiliation.

“Let’s say a youngster falls off a motorcycle,” she stated, “however the insurer was considering, ‘Did somebody run him off the street, or did he hit a pothole the town didn’t fill?’”

Statistics on how a lot cash well being insurers get better by way of passing the buck to different insurers are onerous to seek out. A 2013 Deloitte consulting agency research, commissioned by the Division of Labor, estimated that subrogation helped personal well being plans get better between $1.7 billion and $2.5 billion in 2010 — a tiny slice of the $849 billion they spent that yr.

Medical suppliers might have purpose to hope that payments might be despatched by way of auto or home-owner’s protection, fairly than medical health insurance, as they’re more likely to receives a commission extra.

That’s as a result of auto insurers “are going to pay billed prices, that are extremely inflated,” stated lawyer Ryan Woody, who makes a speciality of subrogation. Well being insurers, against this, have networks of medical doctors and hospitals with whom they negotiate decrease fee charges.

Invoice of the Month Sources

Learn Extra

Decision: Due to his expertise as an lawyer, Woodrum felt assured it might finally all work out. However the common affected person wouldn’t perceive the authorized quagmire and may not know struggle again.

“I hear the horror tales day-after-day from individuals who don’t know what it’s, are confused by it and don’t take applicable motion,” Woodrum stated. “Then they’re a yr out with no fee on their payments.” Or, fearing for his or her credit score, they pay the payments.

After receiving the accident questionnaire, Woodrum stuffed it out and despatched it again. There was no liable third get together, he stated. No driver was at fault.

His little one simply fell off his bicycle.

HealthScope Advantages reconsidered the declare. It was paid in September, two months after the accident. The hospital acquired lower than half of what it initially billed, primarily based on charges negotiated by way of his well being plan.

The insurer paid $7,414.76 of the price, and the Woodrums owed $1,853.45, which represented their share of the deductibles and copays.

Adam Woodrum and his son, Robert, bike close to their residence in Carson Metropolis, Nevada, on Nov. 7.(Maggie Starbard for KHN)

The Takeaway: The mantra of Invoice of the Month is don’t simply write the examine. But in addition don’t ignore scary payments from insurers or hospitals.

It’s not unusual for insured sufferers to be questioned on whether or not their damage or medical situation may need been associated to an accident. On some declare kinds, there may be even a field for the affected person to examine if it was an accident.

However within the Woodrums’ case, as in others, it was an computerized course of. The insurer denied the declare primarily based solely on the medical code indicating a attainable accident.

If an insurer denies all fee for all medical care associated to an damage, suspect that some kind of subrogation is at work.

Don’t panic.

In the event you get an accident questionnaire, “fill it out, be trustworthy about what occurred,” stated Sean Domnick, secretary of the American Affiliation for Justice, a company of plaintiffs legal professionals. Inform your insurer and all different events of the particular circumstances of the damage.

And accomplish that promptly.

That’s as a result of the clock begins ticking the day the medical care is supplied and policyholders might face a statutory or contractual requirement that medical payments be submitted inside a particular time-frame, which might differ.

“Don’t ignore it,” stated Domnick. “Time and delay may be your enemy.”

Invoice of the Month is a crowdsourced investigation by KHN and NPR that dissects and explains medical payments. Do you may have an attention-grabbing medical invoice you wish to share with us? Inform us about it!

This story was produced by Kaiser Well being Information, an editorially unbiased program of the Kaiser Household Basis.

Associated Matters

  • Value and High quality

  • Well being Care Prices

  • Well being Business

  • Insurance coverage

  • Public Well being

  • Invoice Of The Month

  • Emergency Medication

Contact Us

Submit a Story Tip

Leave a reply